Summary
The quality of Amazon Basics brand ABS, PETG, and PLA 3D printing filaments varies significantly across different product lines, based on a detailed analysis of customer reviews from Amazon. Overall, there seems to be a wide discrepancy in user satisfaction, with a sizeable number of both highly positive and highly negative reviews. This analysis revealed that while some customers find these filaments satisfactory, others have reported consistent issues related to filament quality, such as poor adhesion, color inconsistency, and spool winding problems.
Positive Aspects
- Affordability: Numerous customers have noted that Amazon Basics filaments are cost-effective, which makes them accessible for budget-conscious consumers or those needing filament for non-critical applications [#1, #2, #3].
- Good Print Results When Compatible: Some users have experienced good print results, mentioning satisfactory layer adhesion and aesthetically pleasing outcomes when the filaments work well with their specific 3D printers [#4, #5, #6].
- Variety of Colors and Effects: The filaments come in a variety of colors and finishes, including options like silk and luminous, which can be particularly appealing for creative projects [#4, #6, #7].
Negative Aspects
- Inconsistent Quality and Performance: Numerous reviews criticized the filaments for inconsistent quality control, such as varying diameter, poor spool winding, and even the presence of knots [#8, #9].
- Printing Issues: Many users encountered problems such as clogging, poor bed adhesion, and undesirable printing behavior like stringing and warping. These issues often resulted in aborted prints and wasted filament [#10, #7, #11].
- Packaging and Moisture Concerns: Some filaments were reported to have insufficient packaging, leading to exposure to moisture, which adversely affects printing quality [#12, #13].
Detailed Observations
- PLA Filaments: PLA options generally had mixed reviews, with some users appreciating the print quality and finish, while others struggled with adhesion and accurate color representation. Variability in spool winding quality was also a common issue.
- ABS Filaments: Users who successfully printed with ABS noted its robustness but also indicated significant difficulties related to odor, spool sizing for specific printers, and the need for specific environmental conditions (like avoiding drafts) to prevent warping [#14, #15].
- PETG Filaments: Though some users appreciated the strength and finish of PETG, many reports involved complications around stringing and bed adhesion, suggesting a challenging material for beginners or those without the capability to finely tune their printers [#16].
Recommendations for User
- Ensure Printer Compatibility: Before purchasing, verify that the filament diameter and spool sizing are compatible with your printer model.
- Consider Environmental Factors and Printer Settings: For materials like ABS, ensure good environmental control in your printing area. Experiment with printer settings for temperature and speed to optimize print quality.
- Use for Specific Applications: Given its cost-effectiveness, consider using Amazon Basics filament for non-precision or draft projects where higher-quality filament would not provide a cost benefit.
- Storage: Properly store the filaments to avoid moisture absorption. Usage of desiccants and vacuum-sealed containers is recommended, especially if opened spools are stored for extended periods.
- Testing Small Quantities: If uncertain, test small quantities or single spools before committing to bulk purchases to assess the filament’s performance on your specific setup.
References